Auto Insurance for New Drivers in Ontario: What You Need to Know
Getting auto insurance for the first time can feel complicated. Beyond finding a policy, you need to understand what coverage you need, what affects the...
Being considered a high-risk driver can make finding affordable auto insurance more difficult, but it does not mean you are out of options.
Drivers can have difficulty obtaining standard auto insurance for different reasons, including issues related to their driving or insurance history. The result can be higher premiums, fewer insurers willing to offer coverage, or both.
Understanding why you are considered high-risk is an important first step. It can help you make sense of your current insurance options and identify what may need to change before more options become available.
For a broader overview of coverage, premiums, and how auto insurance works in the province, our Ultimate Guide to Auto Insurance in Ontario covers the fundamentals Ontario drivers should know.
In auto insurance, the term high-risk driver generally refers to someone an insurer considers more likely to have a claim or present other underwriting concerns than the drivers it typically insures.
Being considered high-risk can affect both the price you pay and where you can obtain coverage. Some insurers may offer a policy at a higher premium, while others may decide that the driver falls outside their underwriting criteria.
Insurance companies have underwriting rules that determine which risks they are willing to insure. As a result, a driver who does not meet one insurer’s criteria may still have options elsewhere in the market.
The circumstances can also differ significantly. One driver may have several traffic convictions, another may have multiple at-fault accidents, and another may have experienced insurance cancellations. Those situations are not necessarily assessed in the same way.
Understanding the specific reason you’re having difficulty obtaining standard coverage is therefore more useful than focusing only on the “high-risk” label.
Being considered high-risk can limit your choices and make coverage more expensive, but it does not necessarily mean you cannot obtain auto insurance.
Ontario’s insurance market includes insurers that may offer coverage to drivers who do not meet the underwriting criteria of standard-market insurers. Depending on your circumstances, a broker may be able to identify insurers willing to consider your driving and insurance history.
For drivers who are unable to obtain auto insurance through the regular market, Ontario also has mechanisms intended to help eligible drivers obtain the compulsory auto insurance they need.
A decline from one insurer does not necessarily mean you have exhausted your insurance options.
Your driving record and relevant insurance history can affect which insurers will offer coverage and what you pay. The issues below are assessed under Ontario’s rules and each insurer’s approved criteria.
Several traffic convictions or a serious driving offence can affect both your premium and the insurers willing to cover you. The type, number and timing of convictions matter. Give your broker complete information and ask which entries are affecting your quotes. There is no single threshold that applies to every insurer.
At-fault accidents can also affect how insurers assess your driving history. Multiple at-fault accidents may make it more difficult to qualify with some insurers, depending on the circumstances and the insurer’s underwriting rules.
Not every claim has the same insurance implications. Fault, the type of claim, and your overall record can all be relevant because your driving history can impact your auto insurance rates as well as the insurance options available to you.
A licence suspension can create insurance concerns, but the circumstances behind the suspension matter.
If your licence has been reinstated, don’t assume the insurance implications disappear at the same time. The events that led to the suspension may still be relevant when an insurer assesses your driving record.
This is why drivers returning to the road after a suspension should provide accurate information about their history when requesting insurance quotes.
High-risk insurance isn’t only associated with what happens behind the wheel. Your insurance history can matter too.
A late or missed payment is not the same as an auto insurance policy cancellation for non-payment. However, even one non-payment cancellation can make it harder or more expensive to obtain coverage, depending on the insurer and your circumstances.
If you no longer want to renew a policy, contact your broker, agent, or insurer rather than simply stopping payments. Allowing the policy to be cancelled for non-payment can create an insurance-history issue that an intentional cancellation could have avoided.
There is no universal price for high-risk auto insurance in Ontario. Drivers assessed as higher risk may face higher premiums and, depending on their circumstances, fewer insurers willing to offer coverage.
High-risk status is only part of the pricing picture. Your vehicle, location, driving history, coverage choices, and other factors that affect auto insurance rates in Ontario can still influence the premium you’re quoted.
Auto insurance premiums are based partly on the risk an insurer expects to take on. If a driver’s record indicates a higher likelihood of future claims, the insurer may charge a higher premium to reflect that risk.
The impact can extend beyond price. Some standard-market insurers may not offer coverage when a driver falls outside their underwriting criteria, reducing the number of available options.
“High-risk” is a broad description, not a single rating factor. What matters is the driving or insurance history behind that assessment.
The nature, severity, number, combination, and timing of relevant issues can influence how an insurer assesses the risk. That means two drivers who are both considered high-risk may face different premiums and have different insurance options available to them.
Understanding what is affecting your own record is more useful than looking for a single high-risk insurance rate that applies to everyone.
If you have difficulty qualifying for standard auto insurance, there may still be other routes to coverage. The right option depends on your driving and insurance history and what coverage is available to you in the regular market.
Some insurers specialize in drivers who may not qualify for coverage with standard-market insurers. This is often referred to as high-risk or non-standard auto insurance.
These insurers may be willing to consider driving or insurance histories that fall outside another insurer’s underwriting criteria. Coverage may cost more, but it can provide an insurance option when standard coverage is harder to obtain.
Being declined by a standard-market insurer does not automatically mean Facility Association is your next or only option. There may still be insurers in the regular market willing to consider your circumstances.
Facility Association provides access to auto insurance for drivers who are unable to obtain coverage in the regular market.
This is an important distinction: being considered high-risk does not automatically mean you need Facility Association. High-risk or non-standard insurance may still be available through the regular market.
If regular-market coverage cannot be obtained, Facility Association may provide access to the compulsory auto insurance you need to drive legally in Ontario. Coverage through the Facility Association residual market generally costs more than regular-market insurance, so it is worth exploring available regular-market options first.
A broker or agent can help determine which options are available based on your circumstances.
Finding auto insurance when your options are limited may require a more deliberate approach. Providing accurate information, exploring the insurers available to you, and comparing the policies you are offered can help you make a more informed decision.
Working with an insurance broker can be particularly useful because they can help identify insurers that may be willing to consider your driving and insurance history.
Price matters when high-risk insurance can be expensive, but the cheapest quote is not automatically the best choice.
Compare what each policy actually provides, including coverage limits, deductibles, optional protection, payment arrangements, and any important restrictions or conditions. Two quotes with different prices may not provide equivalent protection.
Understanding what auto insurance covers in Ontario can make those differences easier to evaluate before choosing a policy.
There may not be an immediate way to lower high-risk insurance costs, but the factors affecting your insurance can change. The goal is to avoid adding new problems while building a stronger driving and insurance history.
One of the most important things you can do is avoid adding new problems to your driving record.
Driving safely and avoiding new convictions and at-fault accidents gives you an opportunity to build a better record. Because your driving history can affect your auto insurance rates, improvements typically happen gradually rather than after a single renewal.
Preventable insurance-history issues can make an already challenging situation more complicated.
Pay your premiums according to your policy’s payment schedule, and contact your broker or insurer if you need to make changes. If you want to cancel a policy, arrange the cancellation properly rather than simply stopping payments and risking cancellation for non-payment.
An ordinary break in auto insurance is not, by itself, a permitted reason to increase your rate in Ontario. Insurers can consider a lapse only in specified circumstances, such as cancellation for non-payment or a conviction for driving without insurance during the break. Arrange cancellations properly and make sure a vehicle is insured before it returns to the road.
Don’t assume the insurer or insurance market you needed when your record was worse will always be your best option.
As time passes without new convictions, at-fault accidents, cancellations, or other relevant issues, review the market to see whether additional insurance options have become available. Reassessing your policy at renewal can help you avoid staying in a higher-cost market longer than necessary.
There is no universal period during which every Ontario driver is considered high-risk.
How long your insurance is affected depends on what caused the concern, when it occurred, your subsequent record, and the underwriting and rating rules of the insurers considering your application. Different events can remain relevant for different periods.
For that reason, there is no single anniversary or number of years when every high-risk driver automatically returns to standard insurance. What matters is how the relevant history is assessed as your record changes over time.
It may be worth speaking with an insurance broker if you have been declined by an insurer, had a policy cancelled or not renewed, are returning to the road after a licence suspension, or are having difficulty finding suitable coverage.
A broker can help identify insurance markets that may consider your circumstances and compare the coverage available through them. It can also be useful to have your options reassessed after your record improves, particularly if you originally needed non-standard insurance.
Being considered a high-risk driver can make insurance more expensive and limit your choices, but the coverage available to you today does not necessarily define your options forever.
If you are having difficulty finding auto insurance in Ontario, a Regal Insurance broker can assess your circumstances, compare available options, and help you find coverage that fits your current needs.
Getting auto insurance for the first time can feel complicated. Beyond finding a policy, you need to understand what coverage you need, what affects the...
When your teenager starts driving, there’s more to think about than handing over the car keys. You also need to understand how their new licence...
Being considered a high-risk driver can make finding affordable auto insurance more difficult, but it does not mean you are out of options. Drivers can...
No obligation, just great information!