While we hope you don’t need to call us, should you even need to make a claim, this is when our staff really shine. Our goal is to help you every step of the way, hopefully remove some of your stress and be your advocate until your claim is settled.
We are here to help, get you answers and provide you the advice you need, right when you need it.
Before you begin, you’ll need:
Your policy number (or your phone number if you don’t have your policy number handy)
As many details as possible regarding the incident
A police or fire department report (if one was made)
Talk to your Claims Representative
Monday to Friday – 9 am to 5 pm
After Hours Contact Information
We highly recommend you consult with your account manager before reporting your claim but if it is an emergency or happens after hours and needs immediate assistance your insurance company is available 24 hours a day.
Dumfries Mutual: 1-800-235-8784
Gore Mutual: 1-800-265-8600
The Guarantee: 1-888-998-1872
Heartland Mutual: 1-800-265-8813
Portage Mutual: 1-800-340-2439